Aston Villa Women 1-1 Birmingham City Women: Blues Lose 6-5 on Penalties
Martha Harris scores a dramatic stoppage-time equaliser, but Aston Villa claim the bonus point in the Subway Players Cup
Competition: Subway Players Cup
Date: Wednesday, 28 October 2026
Venue: Keys Park, Hednesford
Half-time: Aston Villa Women 0-0 Birmingham City Women
Full-time: Aston Villa Women 1-1 Birmingham City Women
Penalty shootout: Aston Villa Women win 6-5
Birmingham City Women suffered penalty shootout heartbreak against local rivals Aston Villa Women after a dramatic 1-1 draw in the Subway Players Cup. Martha Harris rescued Blues with a stoppage-time equaliser, but Villa ultimately prevailed 6-5 on penalties to claim the additional point.
Amy Merricks’ side looked set for defeat after Mathilde Harviken headed Villa into the lead in the 69th minute. However, Birmingham continued to push forward and were rewarded when Harris finished from close range following an excellent delivery from Lee Geum-Min.
The late goal ensured the derby finished level after 90 minutes, sending the contest to a penalty shootout to determine which side would collect the bonus point.
Although Blues showed considerable determination to recover from behind, the shootout ended in disappointment. Villa goalkeeper Emily Ramsey made a crucial save before Chastity Grant converted the decisive penalty to secure a 6-5 victory for the hosts.
For Birmingham, there was frustration at missing out on the additional point, but their resilience and second-half response provided encouragement.
Cagey Opening as Both Sides Search for a Breakthrough
The local rivalry was evident from the opening exchanges, with both teams working hard to establish control without giving too much away.
Aston Villa threatened first in the sixth minute when the hosts worked the ball back to Missy Bo Kearns on the edge of the penalty area. Kearns found space to shoot, but her effort sailed over Lucy Thomas’s crossbar.
Birmingham responded through Lily Crosthwaite, who drove into the Villa penalty area, created room for herself and forced a good save from Ramsey. It was an encouraging attacking moment for Blues, who looked capable of troubling their opponents when moving the ball forward with pace.
Villa nearly broke the deadlock in the 22nd minute when Georgia Mullett appeared to be through on goal with Thomas away from her line. However, Shannon Cooke produced an excellent defensive intervention, sliding in to dispossess Mullett and prevent a dangerous opportunity.
Cooke’s timely challenge was an important contribution, helping Birmingham survive a significant scare.
The hosts continued to threaten on the counterattack. Just after the half-hour mark, Mia McAulay drove into the Blues penalty area following a quick transition, but Thomas was equal to the effort and made the save.
Birmingham also had reason to feel aggrieved in the 39th minute. Harris delivered a cross into the penalty area, where Veatriki Sarri rose to meet it. Sarri was brought down following a collision with Ramsey, prompting appeals from the visitors, but no penalty was awarded.
Neither side could find the breakthrough before the interval, and the teams went into half-time with the score at 0-0.
Birmingham City Women Improve After the Break
Birmingham emerged from the interval with greater purpose, gradually taking control of the contest and looking increasingly dangerous in the final third.
The visitors moved the ball with more confidence, putting Villa under pressure and forcing the hosts to work harder defensively. Nevertheless, Villa remained a threat, and Cooke was again called upon early in the second half to cut out a dangerous cross inside the penalty area.
Merricks turned to her bench in search of an attacking spark, and Marie Levasseur made an immediate impact after her introduction.
In the 57th minute, the Canadian international won possession high up the pitch and drove towards the Villa goal before cutting the ball back to Lee Geum-Min. The South Korean midfielder struck the ball well, but Ramsey gathered the effort comfortably.
It was another promising opportunity for Blues, who were beginning to create openings and put their opponents under sustained pressure.
Birmingham’s improved performance suggested they could find a breakthrough, but they needed to turn their attacking momentum into a goal.
Mathilde Harviken Puts Aston Villa Ahead
Despite Birmingham’s encouraging second-half display, Aston Villa struck first in the 69th minute.
The decisive moment arrived following a Villa corner. Substitute Mathilde Harviken rose above the Birmingham defence and directed a header back across goal and beyond Thomas to give the hosts a 1-0 lead.
It was a frustrating goal for Blues to concede, particularly after the visitors had started to gain the upper hand following half-time.
Villa’s advantage left Birmingham facing the prospect of a derby defeat. The hosts could now look to protect their lead and exploit the spaces available as Blues committed players forward in search of an equaliser.
Birmingham’s defence continued to battle, with Neve Herron producing another important sliding challenge to halt a promising Villa attack.
At the other end, however, the visitors needed greater precision in the final third if they were to avoid defeat.
Hurtré and Levasseur Combine to Threaten
With ten minutes remaining, Birmingham produced one of their best attacking opportunities of the evening.
Herron delivered a long ball towards Océane Hurtré on the left flank. The French forward drove forward before delivering an early cross towards Levasseur at the far post.
Levasseur battled to reach the delivery, but a recovering Villa defender did just enough to prevent her from making a clean connection. Ramsey was then able to gather the ball, and Villa survived another scare.
The move demonstrated Birmingham’s ability to create opportunities through their attacking options, with Hurtré’s direct running providing another route towards goal.
As the clock continued to tick down, Blues refused to accept defeat and maintained their efforts to find a way back into the contest.
Martha Harris Scores a Dramatic Stoppage-Time Equaliser
Birmingham’s persistence was eventually rewarded in the dying moments.
As the match entered added time, Sarri delivered a dangerous ball into the penalty area, finding Harris in space. The defender rose highest to meet the cross, but her header sailed over the crossbar.
It was a missed opportunity that might have proved costly, but Harris would have another chance to make an impact before the final whistle.
With almost all the added time played, Lee Geum-Min delivered another excellent cross into the penalty area.
This time, Harris made no mistake.
The Birmingham defender struck first time from inside the box, sending the ball beyond Ramsey and into the net to make it 1-1.
It was a dramatic equaliser and a reward for Blues’ determination to keep pushing despite falling behind in the second half.
The goal transformed the mood of the contest, with Birmingham rescuing a point at the very last moment and ensuring the derby would be decided by a penalty shootout.
After trailing for much of the second half, Merricks’ side had demonstrated the character to fight their way back into the game. Harris’s late intervention ensured their efforts were rewarded.
Penalty Shootout Heartbreak for Birmingham City Women
With the match finishing 1-1, the additional point was at stake in the penalty shootout.
Birmingham made a positive start, with Hurtré and Lee Geum-Min both converting their opening penalties.
However, Villa goalkeeper Ramsey then denied Sarri, giving the hosts an opportunity to gain the advantage.
Thomas responded with an important save of her own, keeping Blues in contention by denying Rachel Maltby.
Cooke, Harris and Herron subsequently found the net from the spot as Birmingham continued to battle.
The shootout remained finely balanced, but the decisive moment arrived when Ramsey saved Asato Miyagawa’s seventh penalty.
Grant then converted Villa’s decisive spot-kick to secure a 6-5 shootout victory for the hosts.
For Birmingham, it was a disappointing conclusion to an evening in which they had worked hard to earn a positive result. Although Blues collected a point for the draw, Villa claimed the additional point available for winning the shootout.
Match Analysis: Character and Resilience from Birmingham
There are frustrations for Birmingham City Women to take from this derby, particularly the manner in which they conceded the opening goal.
After improving considerably following half-time, Blues were punished from a set-piece situation that forced them to chase the game.
Their attacking play also offered opportunities for improvement. Birmingham created several promising situations, but it took until the final moments for them to find the finish required to get back on level terms.
However, the response after falling behind was encouraging.
Rather than allowing the setback to derail their performance, Blues continued to push forward, used their substitutes and maintained their belief until Harris finally found the net.
The equaliser was a fitting reward for that determination.
Defensively, Cooke and Herron made important interventions, while Thomas contributed useful saves during the contest and the shootout.
Harris deserves particular recognition for her decisive contribution. Her late goal rescued the draw, and she subsequently converted her penalty as Birmingham continued their fight in the shootout.
Although the result will feel disappointing, the performance demonstrated a willingness to battle until the very end. The challenge now is to turn that resilience into more consistent results.
What the Result Means in the Subway Players Cup
The Subway Players Cup uses a format in which matches level after 90 minutes proceed directly to penalties. Three points are awarded for a victory in normal time, while teams receive two points for winning a shootout and one point for losing it.
Birmingham therefore take one point from the derby, while Aston Villa collect two.
For Blues, the late equaliser prevented a defeat and ensured they left Keys Park with something to show for their efforts. However, losing the additional point on penalties will be frustrating as they look to improve their position in the competition.
The result also highlights the fine margins involved in derby football, where a set-piece goal, a late finish or a penalty can determine the outcome.
Birmingham will take encouragement from their second-half performance, but greater clinical finishing could have helped them avoid the need for a shootout altogether.
Final Verdict: Blues Show Fight Despite Penalty Defeat
Aston Villa Women 1-1 Birmingham City Women (Aston Villa win 6-5 on penalties)
Birmingham City Women showed character to recover from a second-half setback and rescue a draw against their local rivals, only to suffer disappointment in the subsequent penalty shootout.
Harviken’s header gave Villa the advantage, but Harris’s late equaliser ensured that Blues’ efforts were rewarded with a point.
The shootout ultimately went Villa’s way, with Ramsey’s save from Miyagawa and Grant’s decisive penalty settling the contest.
For Birmingham, the overriding feeling will be frustration at missing out on the bonus point. Nevertheless, there were positives in their resilience, defensive commitment and determination to keep fighting.
The late equaliser was a moment of quality and perseverance, and Blues can take encouragement from the fact that they refused to give up when defeat appeared likely.
Final score: Aston Villa Women 1-1 Birmingham City Women
Penalty shootout: Aston Villa Women win 6-5
Keep Right On.
BCFC Fanzine - Bringing you the latest Birmingham City news, views and match reports.